The ECB is interested in four-day tests but does Sportsmail cricket experts do?

The England and Wales cricket board is keen to carry out the mandatory four-day Trial matches from 2023.

The controversial proposal will likely be met by backlash from players and major venues, although the ECB has favored shorter matches to reduce the player’s workload.

But do Sportsmail cricket experts support these plans, or do they oppose them?

PAUL NEWMAN – CRICKET CORRESPONDENT – NO

Of all the stupid ideas dreamed of by modern cricket administrators, this is one of the worst. The tests last for five days. End of. Reducing them one day will ruin the whole rhythm and dynamism of cricket Test. It will become a lesser game.

Just think of some awesome Thursday draws. How about Old Trafford and Oval in the biggest ash series in 2005? What about horror movies inspired by Graham Onions in Cape Town and Centurion here in South Africa 10 years ago.

Is Monty Panesar and Jimmy Anderson in Cardiff in 2009 anyone? Panesar again and Matt Prior in Auckland 2013. And it’s not just attractive – what about the West Indies chasing 322 to win over all the odds at Headingley in 2017. The list is endless.

OK, I know a lot of games end after four days but thinking would be completely different if it was the beginning. It will encourage negative cricket because it will be easier to play for a draw. The longer the game, the better chance of winning the team. And if one day or more is losing rain, you can forget all about a positive result.

Falling tests will ruin the rhythm and a list of memorable games will not occur

Oh god, players find it hard to beat 90 overs in a day now, let alone 98. At Centurion, we lost 10 overs in one day and the next seven days. When Colin Graves said that he supported the four-day Trials after becoming president of the ECB in 2015, he said there should be 105 people in one day. Good luck with that, Mr. Chairman. And don’t forget to turn off the lights when you finally leave the ground.

As soon as they earn more rooms, they will fill it with another Twenty20 tournament or, heaven forbid, over a hundred matches.